Oh, We Have to Pay for That?

Member Group : Keith Rothfus

During my first campaign for Congress in 2010, the national debt for the United States approximated $13 trillion. That year, the expanding debt was an issue that helped propel Republicans to take over the House of Representatives, with a net gain of 63 seats.

There was a lot of energy within the “tea party” GOP those days to stop the profligate spending that President Obama had taken to an art form with his 2009 stimulus and the promises in his unfunded (and unaffordable) Affordable Care Act. The Obama years were on top of robust spending during the “guns and butter” George W. Bush years. In that era, even though the nation had embarked upon the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq, the Bush GOP increased domestic spending on items such as the No Child Left Behind federal education experiment and the new Medicare drug plan. But with the tea party wielding significant influence after the 2010 midterms, then-Speaker John Boehner achieved a remarkable feat for conservatives: an actual reduction in federal discretionary spending in 2011.

Such fiscal discipline is but a distant memory. Now fifteen years later, the national debt has soared $26 trillion, putting us $39 trillion in the hole. Trillion dollar deficits are now accepted as routine, and neither political party has much to say about this new status quo. If you do not think that’s a problem, look at how much the federal government, and in turn, we taxpayers, are paying to finance that debt. Net interest on the debt in FY2010 was $197 billion; this fiscal year it is projected to be $1 trillion. That is $140 billion more than we are spending on defense.

Why does all this matter? We all witnessed several years ago what can happen when federal spending spins out of control. The $2.2 trillion CARES Act in 2020,  the $1.9 trillion American Rescue Plan Act in 2021, the $1.2 trillion infrastructure bill in 2021 and the $900 billion so-called Inflation Reduction Act in 2022 all contributed to the worst inflation in more than 40 years. Crimped family budgets across the country have yet to recover.

And now here we go again. This fiscal year, our budget deficit is projected to be higher than last year’s $1.8 trillion. But wait, that’s before considering the next big ticket item.  Last week, news began to circulate that the Trump administration is teeing up a funding request for $200 billion to pay for the Iran war. That’s a lot of money, particularly in light of some politicians characterizing the action in Iran as not a war but a “limited operation.”

Given our budget mess, Congress needs to scrutinize this war supplemental with precision. In the process, they may find some perspective from past conflicts. In the first fiscal year after the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks, Congress passed a supplemental appropriations bill allocating $20 billion to fund the Global War on Terror efforts in Afghanistan and elsewhere. On inflation adjusted terms, that $20 billion would be worth nearly $37 billion today. In 2011, with 150,000 troops stationed across Iraq and Afghanistan, supplemental funding was close to $159 billion, or $229 billion in today’s dollars. That sounds close to the Administration’s request, but in 2011 we had tens of thousands of troops deployed in two theaters.

I recently suggested that given the unprecedented scale of the attack on Iran, President Trump should have first sought Congressional approval before entering this war. Had he done so, Congress could have considered every angle of this undertaking, including the end goals of the action, the likelihood of achieving such results and the potential casualties among our service members. Congress could also have raised concerns about the economic consequences of this war, from the impact on the federal budget to costs arising from the economic disruptions sure to take place in the energy sector.

But the decision to wage war was made without the input of the people’s representatives, and now we have to pay the price. The question lawmakers now face is whether the war will be paid for by cutting other spending, raising taxes, or putting it on the nation’s already overextended credit card. Knowing how Congress operates, the last option is the most likely. But someday, maybe in the not too distant future, the bill on that credit card will come due, most likely in the form of more inflation. While some politicians may think they have dodged a tax increase on the American people, others will understand what Margaret Thatcher taught fifty years ago: inflation is the cruelest tax. Get ready to pay more.

(Congressman Keith Rothfus served 3 terms in the U.S. House. He is a Notre Dame Law School graduate living near Pittsburgh where he and his wife raised their family. )