‘Eternal Father, Strong to Save’

Member Group : Keith Rothfus

The news last Saturday morning that President Trump had launched a regime-change war against Iran brought to mind the 2013 commencement address I gave at my son’s high school graduation during my first year in Congress. I told the graduates that theirs was the first class in United States history to have had their country at war during the entirety of their schooling from first grade through twelfth grade. I suggested that, to them, it may seem normal to be in a state of constant war; I told them it was not.

Although the wars I had in mind in that 2013 speech eventually ended, skirmishes in other hotspots involving U.S. forces continued: strikes against Al Qaeda affiliates in Africa, actions against Iranian-backed rebels in Yemen, the crushing of ISIS, retribution against Syria for Assad’s use of chemical weapons, and the elimination of Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps leader Qasem Soleimani, who was responsible for the death and maiming of thousands of American soldiers in Iraq. Some of these actions were arguably within the scope of prior congressional authorizations to use military force, others not so much. Operation Epic Fury, the new war with Iran, was launched without any congressional approval. Why does – and should –  congressional authorization matter?

It matters because our Constitution divides responsibility for war between the executive and legislative branches. The President is Commander‑in‑Chief and has inherent authority to conduct foreign affairs and direct the armed forces. Congress, however, holds the power to declare war, raise and support armies, maintain a navy, regulate the armed forces, and control the purse.

Supporters of Trump’s action cite historical examples to support what President Trump is doing. But such prior actions pale in comparison to what is underway now: “major combat operations” (Trump’s words) to eliminate Iran’s threats and to change the government of a nation with more than 90 million people. There is simply no precedent for such an action being taken without prior congressional approval.

The closest analogies may be the first President Bush’s deposing of Panamanian President Noriega and President Obama’s NATO air campaign in Libya. But congressional acquiescence to two prior presidents does not give this, or any, president carte blanche to take us into war. The Libya and Panama actions were far more limited than what is underway in Iran, where day one of the war saw the elimination by airstrike of dozens of Iran’s leaders, including its supreme leader Ayatollah Khamenei.

While there may be concerns over the constitutional basis for Operation Epic Fury, the evil that Iran has done over 47 years of destabilizing the Middle East and maiming, killing, and tormenting Americans cannot be overstated. A listing of places and names suffices as a reminder: Beirut Embassy bombing. Beirut Marine Barracks bombing. Beirut Embassy Annex bombing. TWA 847 hijacking and killing of Navy diver Robert Stethem. Beirut kidnappings and the murder of CIA station chief William Francis Buckley. Khobar Towers. USS Cole. IEDs used against Americans in the Iraq war. All constituted acts of war against the United States. But the US never truly responded in kind. Until last Saturday.

Given all that Iran has done and threatened to do, should the American people, through their elected representatives in Congress, have had a say in the decision to go to war? The Constitution’s grant of war-making power to Congress is not a dead letter. But like so many things over the last 80 years, Congress has acceded to the executive branch’s ever-expanding power.

It is too bad our representatives did not debate this war before it began. They could have probed intelligence findings and perhaps learned they were more reliable than what we were told before the Iraq war. They could have reminded us of the terrible price when intelligence is wrong. They could have pressed for secondary sanctions as an alternative to war. Why, by the way, were we still trading with China when they kept buying Iranian oil?

One other benefit of debating before shooting is the chance to consider all potential outcomes of a war. In the runup to the 2003 Iraq war, one voice on the global stage was standing athwart history yelling Stop! That was John Paul II, who called war “an adventure of no return.” Once it starts, no one knows how it will end, and that is where we find ourselves today. So now, more than ever, Americans should join with the prayer from the Navy Hymn: “Eternal Father, strong to save, whose arm hath bound the restless wave…hear us when we cry to thee.”

(Congressman Keith Rothfus served 3 terms in the U.S. House. He is a Notre Dame Law School graduate living near Pittsburgh where he and his wife raised their family. )