Cheating Our Students, Stealing from Taxpayers, Lying to Parents
![]()
They’re cheating — no, not in Alaska. They’re wasting billions — no, not in Minnesota.
They’re keeping secrets from parents — yes, across Pennsylvania, but now in another way.
Pennsylvania’s education establishment is preparing to lie, cheat and steal — right before our eyes. Tragically, the establishment and teachers’ unions continue to show us they care far more about themselves than they do our children. Truthfulness is not a virtue respected by the Left when protecting power. Arrogantly, the education elites truly believe they know better than parents.
Each spring, Pennsylvania public school students take standardized assessment tests — reading and writing, math and science. And each year, the scores for each school are released to the public, and parents or guardians are given the scores for their student and their school.
The 2026 scores for Philadelphia students haven’t even been released yet — seven months after the students took their tests. Wonder why?
For years, the Pennsylvania scores have been poor and — more or less — stagnant. Many schools have not even reached their pre-Covid levels. And even pre-Covid scores were not exactly awe-inspiring. The majority of our 500 districts have schools where the majority of students are not “proficient” — achieving at the minimum grade level.
But last year, in Philadelphia, 70% of students couldn’t read at grade level and 75% couldn’t do grade-level math.
Still wondering why they’re hiding the test scores from students, parents, and taxpayers?
(Before anyone talks about money, the district’s annual operating budget is approximately $4.6 billion, and it has approved a separate $1.5 billion capital improvement program, spread across six years. Philadelphia is spending over $25,000 per student.)
However, as we learned last week in an education newspaper, these selfish, arrogant elitists aren’t merely content with cooking the books going forward; they want to retroactively lower the standards for tests taken seven months ago!
Historically, Pennsylvania rates the assessment test scores in four ranges: Advanced, Proficient, Basic and Below Basic. Loosely correlating to A and B, C, D, and E and F.
As of last year — on average — approximately 25% of Philadelphia public school students got an A, B or C in their assessments (Advanced and Proficient). 75% scored a D, E or F (Basic or Below Basic) — with nearly 57% getting an F (Below Basic).
Again, any wonder why they want to reconfigure the grading?
Having watched their budget grow by about $1 billion during Gov. Shapiro’s term, with per-pupil spending now exceeding the tuition at Merion Mercy Academy, it’s no longer defensible to allege insufficient funding. (Which it hasn’t been for well over a decade, at least.)
So, what to do if the students can’t reach the benchmarks — lower the benchmarks, of course!
If these folks ran the NBA, they’d lower the rims from 10 feet to six feet. Worse, if they were Eagles fans and were allowed to run the NFL, they’d extend halftime from 20 minutes to a month while they reconfigured the way teams scored … until the Eagles were winners.
If the Pennsylvania State Board of Education gives in to the political pressure from the teachers’ unions and allies, the number of correct answers from the April tests won’t change; but more students will be viewed as “Advanced” even though they would not have qualified under the previous standards.
More A’s and B’s … and fewer F’s — everybody gets a trophy! Except …
The “adults” will be lying to our children. Lying to their parents/guardians. And lying to taxpayers. Never forget that over 60% of the school district’s budget comes from Harrisburg and Washington. The education establishment will be lying to all Pennsylvanians — and to all Americans.
Everyone with common sense, with genuine compassion — a sincere focus on children, not the teachers’ unions, politics or power — knows what’s been going on in most of those schools is wrong. This is just a selfish, arrogant attempt to hide the failure — and further endanger the career paths of these children.
Tell the truth. Look to places like Mississippi and Florida to fix what’s broken. And expand charter schools, support cyber schools and expand education tax credit scholarships (Pennsylvania’s and the new federal credit) to make sure no child is forced to go to a failing school.
Guy Ciarrocchi is a senior fellow with the Commonwealth Foundation. He writes for Broad + Liberty and RealClear Pennsylvania. Follow Guy at @PhilaFreedomGuy
