Right Sizing Pittsburgh Public Schools

Pittsburgh Public Schools (PPS), long plagued by extraordinarily high
spending per pupil but exceptionally weak academic results, also has
been bedeviled by a plunging student census that has led to a gross
building over capacity.
And a researcher at a Pittsburgh think tank says taking action on the
latter could go a long way to begin addressing the former. “Could”
being the operative word.
“The Allegheny Institute has long pointed out that PPS spends an
unconscionable amount per pupil and reductions in expenditures are
desperately needed,” says Alex Sodini, a research assistant there (in
Policy Brief Vol. 24, No. 39).
“School closures could present potential savings on staff and
maintenance costs, while selling the land/buildings to the private sector
places them on the tax rolls,” he stresses.
A six-month study by Education Resource Strategies (ERS),
commissioned by the school board, was conducted in an effort to right-
size PPS’ facilities. On Oct. 15, the consultants delivered their final
recommendations for “opening three new schools, reconfiguring 12
schools and closing 14 schools and 10 facilities, which would reduce the
District’s footprint from 54 to 42 schools.”
And the need for facilities reform had become clear.
“As of the 2023 Annual Comprehensive Financial Report (ACFR), PPS
had 19,764 students but space (functional capacity) for 16,000 more,”
Sodini found.
But the nub of the rub in this proposal contains a major bug, a flaw that
must be rectified.
“Typically, building closures would result in downsizing, driving down
staffing costs for the district,” Sodini reminds. “However, the proposed
reconfiguration of grade levels, programs and course offerings would
likely lead to staff relocations rather than layoffs.”
ERS predicts that “student-facing resources (such as teachers,
counselors, social workers, etc.) would be generally shifted, not
reduced.”
“Furthermore, due to typical attrition rates, headcount reductions
would be expected to remove vacancies rather than filled positions,”
the think tank scholar says, noting that the 2023 ACFR shows PPS had
3,912 total employees, of which 2,232 were instructional.
That said, ERS projects that implementation of its recommendations
would “result in a net change of up to $3 million annually and the
potential reduction in capital investment by more than $50 million.”
Assuming the closures move forward, Sodini stressed there is also no
guarantee that these buildings will make their way onto the tax rolls.
“Any prospective buyer will be asked to detail its plan for the property,
involve and consult the public and work with the City Council member
where the property is located as per a 2021 amendment to PPS’ policy
manual,” Sodini explains.
“If a building is sold to a non-profit, other governmental entity or
retained by the district, it remains tax-exempt,” he adds.
There is $20.3 billion taxable assessed value in the district and another
$11.6 billion that is tax-exempt. The 10 buildings slated for closure total
$50.1 million in assessed value.
“While this is only 0.43 percent of the total exempt property, their sale
would nonetheless ease some of the burden on the district’s budget via
savings on building maintenance and repair,” the think tank researcher
reminds.
“In doing so, PPS also has the opportunity to focus its resources on
providing a better educational experience for students,” Sodini says.
“The decision over whether the ERS plan is the best way to move
forward now rests with the school board.”
Colin McNickle is communications and marketing director at the
Allegheny Institute for Public Policy (cmcnickle@alleghenyinstitute.org).
